a digital common place book | an @s_m_i production | one of a few

Really, Card could have stopped there. Instead, he went on to wonder “whether the victorious proponents of gay marriage will show tolerance toward those who disagreed with them when the issue was still in dispute.” His concern, ostensibly, is that someone might be petty enough not to see his movie simply because he spent years lobbying for laws that treated certain people as less than human. The fallacy he employs here — that calling out hate-speech is intolerance on par with curtailing the human rights of others — is a favorite fallback of cowards and bullies, and a way of evading responsibility for the impact of their words and actions.
- Bears repeating: 

The fallacy he employs here — that calling out hate-speech is intolerance on par with curtailing the human rights of others — is a favorite fallback of cowards and bullies, and a way of evading responsibility for the impact of their words and actions.

Orson Scott Card Responds to Ender’s Game Boycott With Ironic Plea for ‘Tolerance’ | Underwire | Wired.com

We almost expect women athletes to not be classically beautiful or feminine, and therefore we’re not surprised to learn they’re gay. Male professional athletes, by contrast, are thought to be our most masculine specimens. So when they come out as gay, it seems they’re playing against type. Even more than with femininity, masculinity and heterosexuality are widely perceived to be linked. For all the progress that’s been made, there’s still a perception that the bullied gay kid is spending his after-school hours curating a Lana Del Rey Tumblr, not practicing with the varsity basketball team. The bullied teen lesbian? She’s the one on the court.
seldo:

ignitemythoughts:

I hope your mother/girlfriend/sister/friends/everyone asks what happened to your nose. I hope you have to explain that you thought it’d be funny to joke with your friend about raping the drunk girl across the street. I bet you didn’t think that the girl who was walking in front of you would turn around and punch you in the face. You’re a filthy piece of shit and I don’t regret this at all.

So, here’s a thing that happened last night:
My boyfriend and I have been on a mini-vacation, riding bikes south from San Francisco to Big Basin for a few nights, then on to Santa Cruz for some fun beach-town times. We went kayaking and swam and had dinners at lovely restaurants. It was great. Walking down Pacific Avenue back to our hotel on Saturday night, I impulsively took his hand in mine.
My boyfriend thinks I’m weird about hand-holding. Because I really really like it, but at the same time I’m very shy about doing it in public. But hey, we’re on the main commercial street of a liberal California town less than 2 hours away from San Francisco, the gayest town on earth. What could go wrong, right?
And really, nothing serious did. A bunch of people noticed and there were several double-takes — a couple friendly smiles, in fact. But there were also two guys in their early 20s, walking in the opposite direction, who spotted us from twenty feet away and whispered to each other. Then, just as we passed each other, the one nearest to me jabbed his head within an inch of mine and yelled loudly in my ear (just a noise, not a word), then laughed as I flinched away.
I didn’t let this go entirely — I turned and shouted “fuck you too!” They didn’t turn around, and we didn’t stop, and nothing more came of it.
But what I really, really wish I’d done was what this girl did. I wish the moment he invaded my personal space, instead of flinching away, I’d brought my hand up and punched him while kicking his legs out from under him. “Sorry!” I’d have said, as the back of his head smacked into the pavement, “I thought you were going to attack me and I just reacted.”
Because there’s no doubt in my mind why he chose me and my boyfriend to be a dick to. It’s because we were two guys holding hands. He wasn’t yelling at anybody else on the street, either before or after. And even though all he did was yell and laugh, and nothing was hurt but my feelings, the next time I think about holding my boyfriend’s hand I’m going to think about some asshole like him deciding to yell, or do something worse. I’m going to be just that little bit more intimidated, and he’s going to be that little bit more encouraged to do it again. And I’d prefer it be the other way around.
Punching that guy would have been an over-reaction, but it wouldn’t really have been a reaction to that particular incident, it would have been a reaction to a pervasive culture of minor slights, tiny insults, small fears and doubts and injustices, that accumulate a mental weight over time, one that stops me from always doing what I want, like hold my boyfriend’s hand just because I’ve had a lovely night out and I like him.
I live in one of the most gay-friendly parts of the entire world, and yet still sometimes people yell at me just to watch me flinch, because I’m gay. It makes me deeply, deeply angry. And sometimes enough annoying little things like that happen that I want to lash out and hurt someone. 
For nearly everyone nearly everywhere else, things are much worse than they are for me. This is why gay people have Pride parades and support groups, to make us feel good about ourselves, and also why we have high rates of alcoholism and suicide, to try and stop feeling bad about ourselves. This is why, even in countries where we are very nearly equal like the USA, we still fight for the rights we don’t have, like marriage and adoption. Because you have to get the big, symbolic things right in order to fix the little things.
So I think this girl over-reacted, and I wouldn’t really have punched him. But I understand where she’s coming from. Sometimes you want to hurt them back.

Emphasis mine.

Update: ignitemythoughts, the OP, has deleted her account after receiving threats and harassment because she took a stance against rape culture. That is all kinds of fucked up.

seldo:

ignitemythoughts:

I hope your mother/girlfriend/sister/friends/everyone asks what happened to your nose. I hope you have to explain that you thought it’d be funny to joke with your friend about raping the drunk girl across the street. I bet you didn’t think that the girl who was walking in front of you would turn around and punch you in the face. You’re a filthy piece of shit and I don’t regret this at all.

So, here’s a thing that happened last night:

My boyfriend and I have been on a mini-vacation, riding bikes south from San Francisco to Big Basin for a few nights, then on to Santa Cruz for some fun beach-town times. We went kayaking and swam and had dinners at lovely restaurants. It was great. Walking down Pacific Avenue back to our hotel on Saturday night, I impulsively took his hand in mine.

My boyfriend thinks I’m weird about hand-holding. Because I really really like it, but at the same time I’m very shy about doing it in public. But hey, we’re on the main commercial street of a liberal California town less than 2 hours away from San Francisco, the gayest town on earth. What could go wrong, right?

And really, nothing serious did. A bunch of people noticed and there were several double-takes — a couple friendly smiles, in fact. But there were also two guys in their early 20s, walking in the opposite direction, who spotted us from twenty feet away and whispered to each other. Then, just as we passed each other, the one nearest to me jabbed his head within an inch of mine and yelled loudly in my ear (just a noise, not a word), then laughed as I flinched away.

I didn’t let this go entirely — I turned and shouted “fuck you too!” They didn’t turn around, and we didn’t stop, and nothing more came of it.

But what I really, really wish I’d done was what this girl did. I wish the moment he invaded my personal space, instead of flinching away, I’d brought my hand up and punched him while kicking his legs out from under him. “Sorry!” I’d have said, as the back of his head smacked into the pavement, “I thought you were going to attack me and I just reacted.”

Because there’s no doubt in my mind why he chose me and my boyfriend to be a dick to. It’s because we were two guys holding hands. He wasn’t yelling at anybody else on the street, either before or after. And even though all he did was yell and laugh, and nothing was hurt but my feelings, the next time I think about holding my boyfriend’s hand I’m going to think about some asshole like him deciding to yell, or do something worse. I’m going to be just that little bit more intimidated, and he’s going to be that little bit more encouraged to do it again. And I’d prefer it be the other way around.

Punching that guy would have been an over-reaction, but it wouldn’t really have been a reaction to that particular incident, it would have been a reaction to a pervasive culture of minor slights, tiny insults, small fears and doubts and injustices, that accumulate a mental weight over time, one that stops me from always doing what I want, like hold my boyfriend’s hand just because I’ve had a lovely night out and I like him.

I live in one of the most gay-friendly parts of the entire world, and yet still sometimes people yell at me just to watch me flinch, because I’m gay. It makes me deeply, deeply angry. And sometimes enough annoying little things like that happen that I want to lash out and hurt someone. 

For nearly everyone nearly everywhere else, things are much worse than they are for me. This is why gay people have Pride parades and support groups, to make us feel good about ourselves, and also why we have high rates of alcoholism and suicide, to try and stop feeling bad about ourselves. This is why, even in countries where we are very nearly equal like the USA, we still fight for the rights we don’t have, like marriage and adoption. Because you have to get the big, symbolic things right in order to fix the little things.

So I think this girl over-reacted, and I wouldn’t really have punched him. But I understand where she’s coming from. Sometimes you want to hurt them back.

Emphasis mine.

Update: ignitemythoughts, the OP, has deleted her account after receiving threats and harassment because she took a stance against rape culture. That is all kinds of fucked up.
The reality is that despite the very real, the very necessary, and the very life-changing progress we have made in this country in treating people across the sexual orientation spectrum with dignity and respect, America—the world—is not fully represented by Chelsea in New York City. It’s not fully represented by DuPont Circle in Washington, D.C.; the Castro; or West Hollywood. Hell, it’s not even Ft. Lauderdale and its Wilton Manors or Denver’s Capital Hill neighborhood. America is, in large part, small towns like Oxnard, Calif. It’s Sevierville, Tenn. It’s Laramie, Wyo. And it’s Wichita, Kan., where I was eating recently at a local diner and a patron asked me, “Kathy, how do you deal with so many goddamned fags?”